11964

Shelter Island, NY

Total Population

3,129

5-year trend

+13.0%

Median Household Income

$98,409

5-year trend

+20.7%

Median Home Value

$934,900

5-year trend

+34.1%

Median Rent

-$666,666,666

5-year trend

+30.2%

Key Insights

What the data tells us about this area

Median household income is 100% higher than the state average, indicating an affluent area.

Home values are 102% higher than the state average. This area has a competitive real estate market.

57% of adults (25+) have a bachelor's degree or higher, suggesting a highly educated community.

Quick Facts & Insights

Key metrics and how they compare

Household Income

$98,409

100.2% above state avg

Home Value

$934,900

101.6% above state avg

Rent

-$666,666,666

407.6% below state avg

Population Density

3,129 residents

Median Age

42.3 years

Safety Score

74/100

Above average safety

Livability Score

Overall quality of life rating based on key factors

Overall Livability

Fair

Out of 100

Score Breakdown

Amenities

78/100

Cost of Living

58/100

Safety

74/100

Education

55/100

ℹ️ Hover for details

Employment

93/100

Housing

44/100

Weather

69/100

Data Sources & Accuracy

Official Government Data:Demographics and housing statistics are from the U.S. Census Bureau API (American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates). Weather and climate data comes from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) API with official climate normals from the nearest weather station. Crime statistics are from the FBI Crime Data Explorer API, with county-level data when available, otherwise state-level official data.

Modeled Estimates:Schools and some economic indicators are currently modeled using statistical methods based on national averages and regional patterns. For critical decisions, verify with official sources:

Schools: GreatSchools.org or NCES
Note: IPEDS integration for colleges/universities is in progress

Learn more about our data sources and methodology on our Data Sources page.

Interactive Location Map

Shelter Island, NY 11964

Loading map...

Coordinates: 40.9223°, -72.6371°Open in Google Maps

Cost of Living

Compared to national average (100 = US average)

Overall Cost Index

142

Higher than avg

100 = US National Average

Cost Index by Category

Housing

202

Above avg

Transportation

110

Average

Healthcare

105

Average

Groceries

115

Above avg

Utilities

108

Average

Overall

142

Above avg

Economy & Employment

Job market and economic indicators

Labor Force

1,320

Employment Rate

94.2%

Avg. Commute

28 min

Work From Home

Top Industries by Employment

Industry Breakdown

Finance & Insurance

49.2%

Professional & Business Services

27.2%

Construction

12.8%

Educational Services

10.8%

Total Employed

1,244

Total Unemployed

Unemployment Rate

5.8%

Nearby ZIP Codes

Explore surrounding areas

Demographics Overview

Comprehensive population statistics and demographic breakdown

Key Demographic Insightsfor Shelter Island, NY

Median household income is 100% below state average, suggesting more affordable cost of living.

High education levels with 56.7% holding bachelor's degrees or higher, well above national average of 33%.

Low poverty rate of 3.6%, well below national average.

Insights are derived from US Census Bureau data and may not reflect recent changes.

Household Income Distribution

Local Median Income

$98,409

+31.0% vs US

vs State Median

+-100.2%

State: $-55,258,402

Income Distribution

30.8%

Under $50k

18.4%

Over $100k

Lower Income

Middle Income

Higher Income

Data from US Census Bureau ACS 5-Year Estimates

Age Distribution

Population by age group

Household Income Breakdown

Households by income bracket

Education Levels (Age 25+)

Highest education attained

Race & Ethnicity

Demographic composition

Households & Employment

Household Types

Family composition breakdown

Average Household Size: 2.52 people

Total Households

1,228

Family Households

60.1%

Employment by Industry

Where residents work

#1 Industry

Finance

49.2%

#2 Industry

Professional

27.2%

#3 Industry

Construction

12.8%

Total Employed Residents:650

Commute Patterns

How residents get to work

Short Commute

9.5%

Under 10 minutes

Long Commute

4.3%

Over 60 minutes

Work From Home

0.6%

5 workers

Public Transit

10.0%

88 workers

Total Commuting Workers:876

Commute Insights

Good public transit usage (10.0% of workers)

Labor Force Statistics

Employment Rate

94.2%

1,244 employed

Labor Force

1,320

76 unemployed

Unemployment Rate:5.8%

Median Age

42.3 years

Per Capita Income

$49,161

Poverty Rate

3.6%

Moving or Relocating? Get Instant Quotes

Trusted partners for your journey

$20 LEAD

Choice Home Warranty

Protect your home with comprehensive warranty coverage - Get $20 off your first service

Get Free Quote

REWARDS

Hotels.com

Book hotels to explore your new neighborhood before relocating - Earn rewards on every stay

Find Hotels

$10 LEAD

myAutoloan

Compare auto loan rates from top lenders - Get pre-approved in minutes with no credit impact

Get Rates

25% COM

LawDepot

Create rental agreements, leases, and legal documents online - Affordable and attorney-reviewed

Create Documents

20% COM

Auras Insurance

Affordable personal insurance solutions for your new location - Compare rates and save

Get Quote

Sky Blue Credit

Improve your credit score for better mortgage rates - Professional credit repair services

Repair Credit

Sponsored Partners • We may earn a commission at no cost to you